A close corporation's returns were filed by a consultant it says it never authorised. When it asked SARS to reduce the resulting assessments, SARS refused because the corporation's accountant was its public officer. The High Court set that refusal aside, but it also made the point that the obligation to file correct returns stays with the taxpayer.
In short
- Section 93(1)(e)(iii) of the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011 lets SARS reduce an assessment based on a return fraudulently submitted by someone the taxpayer did not authorise.
- The court held that both elements are required: the return must be fraudulent, and the person who submitted it must have lacked authority.
- The court accepted that the accountant was validly appointed public officer. What mattered was that the person who actually filed the returns had no authority.
- The matter went back to SARS for a fresh decision. The court did not find that the returns were fraudulent.
The facts
TEG Asset and Risk Management CC had used the same accountant since 2010 for its accounting and tax returns. The accountant sub-contracted the work to a tax consultant, who held the CC's eFiling codes and submitted its 2017 income tax return and VAT returns for periods between 2015 and 2017. SARS assessed those returns. The CC's attorneys later asked SARS for reduced assessments, on the basis that the returns had been fraudulently submitted by a person the CC never authorised. SARS refused twice, because it regarded the accountant as the CC's validly appointed public officer.
What the court decided
Section 93(1)(e)(iii) allows a reduced assessment where a senior SARS official is satisfied that an assessment was based on a return fraudulently submitted by a person not authorised by the taxpayer. Wright J held that the provision has two separate requirements: the return itself must be fraudulent, and it must have been submitted by someone without the taxpayer's authority. A return is not fraudulent merely because someone other than the public officer filed it, and, as the court put it, "no person could ever be lawfully authorised to submit a fraudulent return".
SARS had given one reason for refusing, namely that the returns were submitted by an authorised person. The CC's evidence that the consultant was never authorised was not disputed, so that reason was wrong. The court reviewed and set aside SARS's decisions of 28 October 2022 and 23 February 2023, sent the matter back to SARS to decide again, and ordered SARS to pay the costs. It did not decide that the returns were fraudulent or that the CC is entitled to reduced assessments; that is now for SARS.
Two further points from the judgment are worth knowing. The court found that the accountant was the CC's validly appointed public officer (paragraph 27); the CC succeeded because the consultant who actually submitted the returns had no authority. And the court criticised how unclearly the CC had presented its case (paragraph 32). A section 93 request should identify clearly who submitted each return, what evidence there is of their mandate or lack of it, what the alleged fraud is, and which assessments are affected. The court set aside SARS's refusals and sent the matter back. It did not cancel the assessments, and it does not give a taxpayer an automatic right to a reduction under section 93(1)(e)(iii).
Why it matters to you
The court was clear that "the obligation to furnish correct, timeous returns remains that of the taxpayer". Engaging an accountant does not transfer that duty, and the route this CC had to use depends on proving both fraud and lack of authority, years after the event. Prevention is far cheaper:
- Keep control of your own eFiling profile, and know whose profile your returns are filed from.
- Give your tax practitioner a written mandate, and ask before any of the work is sub-contracted.
- Review and approve each return before it is submitted, and keep evidence of that approval and of the submission.
- Check the assessment that follows each return, and look at your SARS statement of account and filing history regularly, so that a return you did not expect is picked up early.
- When you change practitioner or public officer, update your details with SARS and remove old access promptly.
- Authorised practitioner access through SARS is the right route. Never share your own eFiling username and password.
If you are unsure who has access to your eFiling profile, or what has been filed in your name, we can help you check.
Sources: TEG Asset and Risk Management CC v CSARS (2023-110354), High Court, Gauteng Division, Johannesburg, 8 October 2026; Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011, section 93(1)(e)(iii). The judgment is marked not reportable.
Technical review: 18 November 2026. General information, not advice; confirm your own facts before acting.